TECHNICAL & SAFETY ARTICLES
return to b47ha
NEW TECHNICAL HAI VIDEO LINK RECOMMENDED BY CAPT. STEPHEN FORD #38:
SURVIVING THE WIRES ENVIRONMENT VIDEO
I am pleased to report that BHT's Chief Service Officer and Customer Support Senior Vice President Shane Eddy has just declared all Bell 47 operational technical publications will be placed on the net and DVD coming 2008. This 24/7 schedule will include availability to all B47HA members.
This industry leading service provides all historical and current documentation associated with each Bell model will be provided via the Web, including: Flight Manuals and Supplements, Manufacturers Data Sections, Maintenance Manuals and Supplements, Illustrated Parts Breakdown Manuals and Supplements, Component Repair and Overhaul Manuals, Installation and Service Instructions, Standard Practices Manuals, Structural Repair Manuals, Special Tools Illustrated Parts Manual, Alert Service Bulletins, Technical Bulletins, Operational Safety Notices, Information Letters as well as FAA and Transport Canada Airworthiness Directives.
B47HA has proven to BHT through our numerous mutual show appearances, effective self management of our war on bogus parts and helos, and the countless acts of successful support that we assist their Montreal Canadian office with that the Bell 47 is alive and well. BHT's inclusion of the 47 concerning their publications is a landmark decision that will benefit B47HA members in the years to come.
Victory is ours and we are to be congratulated for our hard work and singular agenda that BHT admires and respects. I would ask members to send testimonials into us expressing their thanks to B47HA concerning what we have done for them to be placed on our new testimonial page. ceo@bell47helicopterassociation.org
Best wishes,
Joey Rhodes
1200 Hour Overhaul/Inspection; An Owner’s Perspective
BY NEAL TOLER
When is it time to overhaul your Bell 47 helicopter prior to reaching 1200 hours in service? To every Bell 47 owner, operator, A&P technician, etc. this question needs to be addressed whether it be from an economic or safety standpoint.
As for economics the first question an owner will ask is “How much is this going to cost me?” Speaking from experience I rarely quote a firm price to the numerous Bell 47 owner’s who contact me concerning 1200 hour overhaul/inspection. Obviously some items are a given; if a retirement item has time remaining and upon approved inspection methods is found to be airworthy then the owner is well satisfied. To the contrary should the opposite occur then be prepared to stand behind your findings, remember you (as the A&P) are accountable as a skilled professional, don’t allow an inexperienced maintenance opinion to overrule your good judgment. If the Bell 47 owner respects your work they’ll also accept the fact that a good overhaul/inspection estimate is just that (an estimate) and upon further investigation and disassembly additional cost for both labor and replacement parts should be factored into the equation.
Safety is another one of those key words we hear so often yet how many of us actually do practice it? What does it mean to be safe? Are we born with it? Is there a class offered titled “Safety 101 For A&P Technicians?”. I’m sure we could debate safety for several hours during Heli-Expo 2004 (Las Vegas) but let’s concentrate on promoting the Bell 47 instead. During Rotorfest 2003 I was asked the question “What does it mean to be safe?” I explained it this way; you are a home plate umpire (early one Saturday morning) during what every 8 year old player would subconsciously label as their “I have to win this one or no Dairy Queen for a week” World Series. On a 3-2 pitch you call out little Johnny much to the dismay of the coach and every imaginable family member that armchair quarterbacks the following Sunday afternoon. So what correlation exists between being an A&P and umpiring? It’s simple, the pitch was either a ball or a strike; not close to a ball or close to a strike, the pitch was one or the other. The same principle applies to safety around your Bell 47 whether it be during preflight, post flight, maintenance, inspection, etc.. Know the strike zone, refer to the rulebook if necessary; know your Bell 47, refer to the maintenance manual since it’s by your side. Is that chip on the tail rotor gearbox magnetic plug a pending problem or break in fuzz? Not sure? Contact a fellow Bell 47 A&P for a second opinion after emailing a digital photograph, this way the person views what you are viewing. Also consider contacting the A&P who overhauled the tail rotor gearbox and review their maintenance/overhaul procedures without rushing to a conclusion. I also like to refer to the NTSB accident investigation site paying special attention to component failures that may have lead to an accident. Remember accidents just don’t occur, there is always a chain of events leading up to the occurrence since you can’t pull it over to the curb at 90 knots and 1500 agl.
So we’re back to the question concerning 1200 hour overhaul/inspection. Speaking from experience I was curious to determine why the oil cooler was leaking on my Bell 47G2A1 (referred to as “old yeller”) during the early March of 2003. Not from a selfish standpoint but this Bell 47 would be found next to the word dependable in any dictionary; 1130.8 SMOH in 1997 and routine scheduled maintenance with a few hiccups included since purchase in April 1993. My initial plan was to operate the helicopter until 1200.0 hours (maintenance hobbs) and either trade for a larger turbine powered Bell product or sell the helicopter outright as run out. Time for accountability to appear (and the Brinks truck) as I discovered the center frame structure near the oil cooler was severely corroded thus allowing the oil cooler to vibrate during flight. Maybe severely corroded is an understatement, upon further inspection (via paint removal) I discovered the center frame structure was cracked 180 degrees, to my total disbelief (with a firm pull) the structure completely failed and I could clearly see the internal corrosion. Decision time now arrived on scene, needed to finish up power line patrol before the trees bloom but if the internal corrosion was that high then I can’t trust any part of the remaining center frame since I really enjoy the VO-435-A1F Lycoming following me around when I fly. I contacted the electric co-op to relay the news, they’re nice folks and like my flying so we agree to resume patrol flights during the upcoming winter months. Let the games begin! It’s a Sunday afternoon and the Bell 47 is resembling the Johnny Cash hit “One Piece At A Time” only in reverse since the parts were coming off versus going on.
Now Southern Illinois is a beautiful region during the
springtime but can be very unpredictable when it comes to weather. Despite an
unusually wet spring I was able to successfully disassemble and strip the
airframe paint (outdoors) via what seemed like an endless supply of mild blast
media and paint stripper. My suggestion to any Bell 47 owner is always observe
the proper safety precautions/manufacturer recommendations when it comes to
bead blasting and paint stripping; the blast media will disperse in all
directions from both pressure (120 psi) and wind conditions while paint
stripper is unforgiving on almost any contact surface. My experience would
suggest staging all Bell 47 parts in a climate controlled environment free of
moisture, dirt, chemicals ,etc. both prior to and after any paint removal
process.
Fast forward to May 2003. Several airframe/engine accessories have returned safely upon successful completion of overhaul requirements. The owners of our local True Value would smile when I came thru their door toting box after box of alternators, magnetos, starters, actuators and camshafts for shipment. Remarkably the biggest boxes for UPS to handle contained interior seat cushions, floor mats and vertical firewall furnishings since these items required exact duplication for reinstallation. As for heaviest it would have to be a toss up between a VO-435-A1F Lycoming crankshaft or the engine case halves, perhaps Tony (our dependable UPS package car driver) could answer this question better than I. Bottom line is whatever you schedule for shipment and regardless of where it’s going don’t skimp on packing material, although the product name escapes me I vividly remember the mid to late 70’s luggage commercial of the caged gorilla handling a suitcase. Now just imagine that’s your engine/rotor tachometer instrument enclosed. Fortunately I’m within 120 highway miles of an FAA Certified Repair Station in reference to magnetic particle inspection, in this case I prefer to deliver the parts myself although I place a lot of faith in the ‘big brown truck.’ What a great working relationship; drive up in the morning, unwrap all those airworthy (hopefully) main rotor transmission parts, assist the lead technician, rewrap all the parts and drive home later that afternoon.
Now to the good stuff. Based upon experience I would recommend paying particular attention to these areas (in concert with the Bell 47 Maintenance & Overhaul Instructions) while performing a 1200 hour overhaul/inspection.
If your Bell 47 has a history of spraying an initial sign of internal corrosion (due to repeated chemical exposure and daily washing) might be the 47-360-181-51 tubes that lend support to the cabin structure. The tube(s) are in close proximity to the lower door frame (both sides), perhaps their near vertical installation might lend itself to trapping both moisture and chemical residue.
Thank goodness one of our Bell 47 Helicopter Association members submitted a technical tip concerning the importance of properly inspecting, repairing, replacing and calibrating instruments and their associated piping. Some of the wiring in my Bell 47G2A1 appeared original but didn’t require replacement, I did however replace several electrical plugs, connectors, etc.. It appears over the years that flight time, vibration and atmospheric conditions have taken their toll so the statement “the best form of maintenance is preventive maintenance” would certainly apply in this situation. As A&P technicians we are limited to removal and reinstallation pertaining to instruments, prior to reinstallation always verify the helicopter operational limits (red line, green arc, yellow arc, etc.) are correct assuming an instrument repair station might have returned the instrument in airworthy condition without the required markings.
I replaced the original center frame on our Bell 47G2A1 with a freshly overhauled/repaired 47-322-241-143 center frame that was located on the “left coast.” As for total time on the original center frame I can only assume it to be in sinc with airframe total time since the helicopter maintenance records reflected nothing to the contrary. Should this statement hold true the original center frame total time would be just shy of 6000 hours, more importantly how many acres of chemicals had it supplied support for since 1967? The corrosion was detected in numerous locations on the original center frame thus warranting its’ transport to an approved facility for further evaluation, I’ll provide a follow up story should one be appropriate.
Main rotor mast internal corrosion? Look for it and if in doubt refer to the informative story graciously submitted by a fellow member on the Bell 47 Helicopter Association website. You know the main rotor mast is one of those Bell 47 parts I prefer to pack and drive (if practical) to an FAA Certified Repair Station for inspection. Remember the gorilla and the suitcase…
There’s only one position concerning a gimbal ring and your Bell 47, refer to ASB 47-76-4 should airworthiness issues arise. My official stance is any gimbal ring assembly below a –23 makes an excellent cereal bowl; don’t hesitate to utilize 1-800-BELL-250 to confirm the –23 gimbal ring you are about to acquire is authentic.
Most FAA-PMA engine mounts are treated internally with hot linseed oil prior to delivery; primer and paint adhesion can be challenging even under ideal circumstances.
Send the oil cooler in for some well deserved maintenance, take care of it and it’ll take care of you and your freshly overhauled engine. I wouldn’t recommend reapplication of paint by the overhaul facility although they would probably do an excellent job; tape off the cooling fin region and paint it yourself. Upon reinstallation and reaching your first 100 hour inspection back flush the fin area by applying sufficient water pressure to loosen any accumulated dirt, trash, grass, etc. that might affect cooling capability. Verify the engine spark plugs/wiring harnesses are installed prior to this task since moisture might lead to corrosion where the spark plug barrel and wiring harness ‘cigarette’ meet. If a dirty main rotor blade (leading edge) costs you and additional 1” of manifold pressure due to drag how much $ will a dirty oil cooler cost you at engine maintenance intervals? On a related note I ended up replacing both the oil pump body assembly and gear set on the Lycoming VO-435-A1F engine due to excessive wear. It appeared something had invaded both the oil pump body assembly and gear set thus inflicting an appreciable amount of damage due to rotation. Needless to say (whatever it was) there was a good possibility it also invaded the oil cooler.
Trying to reinstall new AN hardware into that freshly painted collective jackshaft? Under ideal circumstances sometimes the difference between go/no-go is cadmium plating on the new bolt. Also remember to reinstall those small cabin screws prior to refinishing, this will prevent a primer/paint combination that can make screw installation quite a challenge.
F900 torque seal is available in various colors and readily available for purchase thru numerous aircraft suppliers. I prefer to utilize green, red and white since these three colors seem more resistant to fading from environmental factors including temperature and direct sunlight. Regardless of your color preference torque seal is especially helpful when introducing a new helicopter flight candidate to their first preflight inspection.
Replace Lord mounts at normal engine change intervals if deteriorated or worn. Replace immediately if any of the following conditions exist; edges of mount clamps are striking center frame support bracket during engine operation, separation between rubber and metal has progressed approximately 120 degrees around the circumference of either inner or outer member, separation has reached a depth of ¼” the length of the Lord mount at any point, flex cracks in rubber have developed to a depth of ¼”.
Don’t forget to remove the 47-612-800-35 gasket if overhaul exchanging your engine adapter plate.
Check torque the main rotor mast nut at 25 hours time in service after initial installation.
Prior to reinstallation visually verify the carburetor throttle shaft is the proper length and will fit properly with the 47-631-360-1 adapter on the carburetor to cam box shaft assembly. On occasion even the highest quality overhaul facility can make a mistake.
Visually inspect the region where the tail rotor gearbox output shaft and 410241 seal interact. I detected wear (groove) around the output shaft circumference and opted to purchase a new output shaft. The corrective action was expensive but the alternative could be extremely costly.
In summary there are many similarities pertaining to 1200 hour overhauls/inspections despite variances in Bell 47 geographic ownership and operating conditions. Luckily for this Bell 47G2A1 owner/operator the helicopter was inspected and approved for return to service in early July 2003; it’s a rewarding feeling to know if something’s worth doing it’s worth doing right the first and only time. Good indication of a quality 1200 hour overhaul/inspection might be helicopter performance during the first 100 hours back in operation. Good indication of a quality A&P technician might be observed in those slightly torn, tattered and greasy pages (front to back) of the Bell 47 maintenance manual.
I would not immediately suspect the spark plugs because if I interpret your message correctly, the engine seems smooth enough at operating RPM. Wire-electrode spark plugs perform best in VO engine installations, I have little experience with massive electrode plugs. Depending on the age and type of plugs, it is not impossible that a contribution from massive electrode plugs may result in your roughness. Additionally, I would tend to eliminate the engine harness because a fault within the magneto - spark plug wiring harness usually results in roughness at all RPM levels.
I hope you have the 1200 series Bendix-Scintilla magnetos which have always provided best service and reliability in the VO engine. A faulty magneto may not produce the desired spark intensity at low RPM while producing an apparently acceptable spark at high RPM. If the points and mag timing check out acceptable, I would suggest the magnetos as next investigation target. To verify the magnetos it may be necessary to remove them for bench test under load.
While on the corrosion subject, The 47 center frame & tail boom can develop internal tubular corrosion just from aging, a easy way to find if this condition exists is to use a adjustable automatic type center punch, which can be adjusted on the low-blow side and punch along the lower side of the tubing every 4 or 5 inches ( use scotch tape on the tube so as not to damage the paint) if there's serious internal corrosion the sound will be muffled or soft, if its OK the snapping sound will be sharp & loud.
"PLAN YOUR WORK AND WORK YOUR PLAN - THE PF"
By Joey Rhodes, Com/Corp. pilot.
When I watch people take their helicopters out of their hangars I am very interested in watching their personal ritual of "The Pre-Flight (PF)." I would venture that if I lined five 47s up in a row, I would probably see five very interesting and varying PFs. Finally, I must add that there is another adjective that shouldn't be listed - "Frightening!"
The "PF" is probably the most safety oriented task that is still the responsibility of the pilot. This responsibility not only places the safety of the helicopter in the hands of the pilot, but also the lives of the passengers who have placed their trust in their captain to take them into the heavens AND RETURN.
Most of the time people become too comfortable with their 47s and make it a "routine." The problem with a routine is that it becomes far less challenging as time marches on. When it is time to do your 47s PF, start with this in mind, "This trip could end in disaster and why?" This should give a pilot pause to carefully look at each section of their PF with more interest.
Remember, a written PF will monitor your steps. So take some time to get with your mechanic and review the proper guidelines to a safe PF. Manuals were written to be followed, so make sure you have one.
I have noticed "Good pilots plan their work and work their plan." We at B47HA are very safety oriented and we make it a point at our events to include seminars or workshops to that effect. The next time you attend a B47HA Event join with us in one of our Bell 47 walk arounds (Hopefully with my good BHT Friend Don Maguire) and you will definitely have a plan to work for your next PF.
The benefit of a safe PF is that it will help keep you alive to fly another day.
return to b47ha